Each year, the Arizona Commission on the Arts relies on the assistance of volunteers from all over the state to review grant applications and offer recommendations for funding to our Governor-appointed Board of Commissioners. Their work is fundamental to our grantmaking, but who are they? Where do they come from? How are they selected? What are their qualifications?

The Ideal Panelist

The Arts Commission looks for panelists who are willing to commit considerable time and energy to the review process and who exhibit sensitivity in making constructive critical judgments.

Grant applications submitted to the Arizona Commission on the Arts are reviewed by panels composed of community members, arts professionals, educators, artists and others actively involved in the nonprofit and service sectors. Because their work is so fundamental to our grantmaking, the Arts Commission looks for panelists who are willing to commit considerable time and energy to the review process and who exhibit sensitivity in making constructive critical judgments.

Potential panelists are identified through both an internal and external nomination process. Arts Commission staff members are always on the lookout for candidates, while individuals can recommend themselves or others for consideration via an online nomination form.

Submit Your Nomination

Nominees must be at least eighteen years of age, live in Arizona and have experience in one of more of the following areas:

  • An artistic discipline
  • Arts learning
  • Financial or organizational management of nonprofit organizations
  • Public art issues and acquisition procedures
  • Community-based arts projects

Assembling a Panel

On a practical level, assembling a grant review panel is a bit like arranging seating at a fundraising event or casting a theatrical production.

CC_AZcountiesBeyond an individual candidate’s qualifications, however, Arts Commission staff must also consider the overall makeup of the panel and how well it reflects the diversity of the state. Therefore, the Arts Commission also considers the following when appointing panelists:

  • Gender
  • Geographic representation
  • Cultural background
  • Balance among the professional groups encompassed by the arts, such as practitioners, administrators, and educators.

On a practical level, assembling a grant review panel is a bit like arranging seating at a fundraising event or casting a theatrical production. For our Community Investment Grant program, which receives hundreds of applications each year, several separate panels are required. Candidates are identified, their names are written on Post-It notes, and these notes are arranged (and rearranged) on larger sheets representing individual review panels. The process spans weeks and at least two walls of the Arts Commission’s conference room.

The Panel Review Process

Participants experience a new perspective on the grantmaking process, obtain insights into what makes a superior grant application, and enjoy an opportunity to meet and work with a diverse group of Arizona leaders, educators, and creatives.

Once the panelists are selected, Arts Commission staff provide extensive training on the review process, the program objectives, and the evaluation criteria. Panelists are then given several weeks to review the application materials and are required to submit a preliminary evaluation at least one week prior to the panel meeting.

When the panelists convene, the meeting is chaired by Arts Commission board members and Commission staff is on-hand to further ensure that panel discussions stay on track and remain focused solely on the published criteria. Discussion time is dedicated to each application and each is given serious and thoughtful consideration.

This process requires a great commitment of time and mental energy. For many panelists, attending the panel meeting also means a lengthy drive from their corner of Arizona to the meeting location. Each and every panelist makes a significant sacrifice to participate. On the other hand, participants experience a new perspective on the grantmaking process, obtain insights into what makes a superior grant application, and enjoy an opportunity to meet and work with a diverse group of Arizona leaders, educators, and creatives.

An Invitation

If you believe you have something to contribute to this vital process, we invite you to nominate yourself today. You are also welcome to nominate qualified individuals other than yourself. Being nominated does not guarantee that you will be appointed to serve on a panel, but you will be considered and added to the Arts Commission’s potential panelist list for future consideration.

Submit Your Nomination